Employee Benefit Plan Audit Services

Specialized Audit Expertise for Employee Benefit Plans

Employee benefit plan audits require more than general audit experience. They require professionals who understand the specialized accounting, reporting, and regulatory requirements affecting retirement and employee benefit plans.

WCS provides employee benefit plan audit services for defined contribution plans, including 401(k), 403(b), and Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs), as well as defined benefit plans. Our experience includes plans with total assets ranging from under $5 million to more than $500 million.

Our dedicated employee benefit plan professionals bring in-depth knowledge of U.S. generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP), the Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA), and U.S. Department of Labor (DOL) requirements to every engagement.

That specialized experience allows our team to quickly understand each plan, conduct an efficient audit, and help plan sponsors navigate the increasingly complex financial reporting and compliance environment surrounding employee benefit plans.

We are proud to be an American Institute of CPAs (AICPA) Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center member firm.

To learn more about our Employee Benefit Plan Audit Services, contact David Crisp, Partner, CPA at DavidC@wcscpa.com or 410.838.2237.

AICPA Employee Benefit Plan Audit Quality Center member logo

Employee Benefit Plan Audits Require Specialized Experience

An employee benefit plan audit isn’t simply another financial statement audit.

Benefit plans operate within a specialized regulatory environment, and audit requirements can involve participant data, contributions, distributions, investments, eligibility, plan provisions, financial reporting, and regulatory filings.

Errors can create additional work for plan administrators and may expose plan sponsors to unnecessary compliance risk.

That’s why experience matters.

WCS has developed a dedicated team of professionals focused on employee benefit plan audits.

Our team’s experience with benefit plan accounting and auditing allows us to identify potential issues, understand plan documentation, and work efficiently with plan sponsors, administrators, recordkeepers, and other service providers involved in the audit process.

The objective is straightforward:

Perform a high-quality, efficient audit while helping plan sponsors better understand and manage their financial reporting responsibilities.

Employee Benefit Plans We Audit

WCS provides independent audit services for a variety of employee benefit and retirement plans, including defined contribution plans such as 401(k) and 403(b) plans, defined benefit plans, and ESOPs.

401(k) Plan Audits

401(k) plans are among the most common employer-sponsored defined contribution retirement plans, and many plans are subject to annual independent audit requirements.

WCS performs 401(k) plan audits for organizations with plans of varying sizes and complexity.

Our professionals understand the financial reporting, participant, contribution, and plan-administration issues that commonly arise during a 401(k) audit and work closely with plan sponsors and service providers to make the engagement as efficient as possible.

403(b) Plan Audits

Nonprofit organizations, educational institutions, and other eligible employers commonly maintain 403(b) plans, a type of defined contribution plan.

These plans have their own administrative and compliance considerations.

WCS provides 403(b) plan audit services designed to help plan sponsors address applicable financial reporting and audit requirements while navigating the specialized characteristics of their retirement plans.

Defined Benefit Plan Audits

Defined benefit plans can involve complex financial reporting and actuarial considerations.

WCS performs independent audits of defined benefit pension plans, including plans with complex financial reporting, investment, and actuarial considerations.

Our team coordinates with plan sponsors and applicable third-party professionals to obtain the information needed to conduct an efficient, thorough audit.

ESOP Audits

Employee Stock Ownership Plans present specialized accounting and auditing considerations because employer securities can represent a significant portion of plan assets.

WCS performs ESOP audits and understands the specialized financial reporting and audit considerations associated with employee stock ownership plans.

Our benefit plan professionals work with plan sponsors and their service providers to understand the plan’s structure and address the information required for the audit.

Does Your Employee Benefit Plan Need an Audit?

One of the most common questions plan sponsors ask is whether their plan requires an independent audit.

The answer depends on the plan’s circumstances and applicable Department of Labor requirements.

Employee benefit plans that meet applicable large-plan filing requirements generally must include audited financial statements with their annual Form 5500 filing, although specific rules and exceptions can apply.

As a general rule, an employee benefit plan with 100 or more participants at the beginning of the plan year is considered a large plan and generally must include audited financial statements with its Form 5500 filing. For defined contribution plans, such as 401(k) plans, the participant count is generally based on individuals with account balances at the beginning of the plan year.

Under the 80–120 participant rule, a plan with between 80 and 120 participants at the beginning of the plan year may generally continue filing in the same category as the prior year. Accordingly, a plan that previously filed as a small plan may continue to qualify for the small-plan audit exemption until its participant count exceeds 120, provided it meets the applicable requirements.

WCS can help plan sponsors understand their plan’s audit requirements and coordinate the audit process with the plan’s Form 5500 filing timeline.

Not sure whether your plan needs an audit?

Talk with David Crisp, Partner, CPA.

What’s Included in an Employee Benefit Plan Audit?

The exact scope of an employee benefit plan audit depends on the plan type and its characteristics.

During an engagement, auditors may evaluate areas involving:

  • Plan financial statements
  • Participant eligibility
  • Employee contributions
  • Employer contributions
  • Participant accounts
  • Benefit payments and distributions
  • Investments
  • Plan expenses
  • Participant loans
  • Administrative processes
  • Plan documents
  • Internal controls
  • Required financial statement disclosures
  • Information used in connection with Form 5500

The objective of the audit is to express an independent auditor’s opinion on the plan’s financial statements.

Because employee benefit plan audits involve information maintained by multiple parties, coordination is especially important.

Plan sponsors may need to obtain information from internal personnel, third-party administrators, recordkeepers, custodians, trustees, investment providers, and other service organizations.

An experienced benefit plan audit team understands how these pieces fit together.

What to Expect During an Employee Benefit Plan Audit

Every plan sponsor wants to know what the audit will actually involve, especially the first time through.

While every engagement is tailored to the plan, most WCS employee benefit plan audits follow a similar path.

  1. Initial planning meeting. We meet with your team to understand the plan, its service providers, any changes during the year, and your Form 5500 filing deadline. Together we set a timeline that works for your HR and finance staff.
  2. Information request. We provide an organized list of the documents and data we’ll need, well in advance of fieldwork, so your team and your service providers have time to gather them.
  3. Fieldwork. Our benefit plan professionals perform audit procedures over areas such as contributions, distributions, participant data, investments, and plan expenses. Much of this work can be completed remotely to limit disruption to your staff.
  4. Follow-up questions. As testing progresses, we follow up on open items and work directly with your recordkeeper, custodian, or third-party administrator when we need additional information.
  5. Draft financial statements. We discuss the draft financial statements and audit findings with plan management before the audit is finalized, allowing sufficient time to address outstanding matters.
  6. Final audit report. Once open items are resolved and management has approved the financial statements, we issue the independent auditor’s report.
  7. Form 5500 coordination. In addition to employee benefit plan audits, WCS provides Form 5500 and Form 8955-SSA preparation services. Our coordinated approach to audit and filing services helps streamline the process, improve communication, and support timely completion of required filings.

Throughout the process, you’ll know where the engagement stands, what’s outstanding, and what comes next.

Preparing for an Employee Benefit Plan Audit

Good preparation can significantly improve the efficiency of an employee benefit plan audit.

Before fieldwork begins, plan sponsors should be ready to provide the documentation and information the audit team requests.

Depending on the plan, this may include:

  • Current plan documents and amendments
  • Form 5500 information
  • Participant census data
  • Payroll information
  • Contribution records
  • Distribution information
  • Participant loan information
  • Investment statements
  • Trustee or custodian reports
  • Service provider information
  • Prior-year financial statements
  • Applicable contracts and agreements
  • Internal accounting records

WCS works with clients before the audit to communicate information requests and help establish an organized process.

The earlier potential issues are identified, the less likely they are to create delays near filing deadlines.

Getting ready for your plan’s audit?

Talk with David Crisp, Partner, CPA, about timing, scope and what to prepare.

Common Issues That Can Surface During a Benefit Plan Audit

Employee benefit plans involve numerous transactions and administrative processes throughout the year.

Even well-managed plans can encounter issues.

Areas that may deserve attention include:

Timely Remittance of Participant Contributions

Employee contributions withheld from payroll need to be transmitted to the plan in accordance with applicable requirements.

Delays can create compliance concerns and may require corrective action.

Plan Eligibility

Plan sponsors need processes to identify when employees become eligible to participate under the plan.

Employer Contributions

Employer matching or other contributions should be calculated and funded in accordance with plan provisions.

Participant Distributions

Distributions should be properly authorized, calculated, and recorded.

Participant Loans

Plans that permit participant loans must administer those loans in accordance with plan provisions and applicable requirements.

Plan Document Compliance

A plan should operate consistently with its governing documents.

Differences between written plan provisions and actual administrative practices can create issues requiring attention.

Internal Controls

Effective internal controls can reduce administrative errors and help plan sponsors maintain reliable financial and participant information.

Identifying these issues is one reason specialized employee benefit plan experience matters.

Internal Controls & Benefit Plan Best Practices

A strong employee benefit plan requires more than an annual audit.

It requires reliable processes year-round.

WCS works with plan sponsors to understand the internal controls surrounding plan administration and can communicate observations or recommendations identified during the audit process.

Areas of focus may include controls surrounding:

  • Payroll and participant contributions
  • Eligibility
  • Participant data
  • Employer contributions
  • Distributions
  • Loans
  • Investment information
  • Plan expenses
  • Reconciliations
  • Financial reporting
  • Service-provider information

Strong controls can help reduce errors, improve the reliability of plan information, and make future audits more efficient.

Working With Your Plan’s Service Providers

Most employee benefit plans rely on multiple outside providers.

These may include:

  • Third-party administrators
  • Recordkeepers
  • Custodians
  • Trustees
  • Investment advisors
  • Payroll providers
  • ERISA attorneys
  • Actuaries

This can make coordination one of the most important parts of the audit process.

WCS works with plan sponsors and their service providers to obtain the information needed for the audit and address questions that arise during the engagement.

Our experience allows us to understand what information is needed, where it may reside, and how the various components of plan administration affect financial reporting.

Have questions about your plan’s controls or service providers?

Talk with David Crisp, Partner, CPA.

Why Choose WCS for Your Employee Benefit Plan Audit?

A Dedicated Employee Benefit Plan Audit Team

Employee benefit plan auditing is a specialized area of practice at WCS.

Our professionals bring focused experience to these engagements rather than treating benefit plan audits as an occasional extension of general financial statement auditing.

Experience Across Multiple Plan Types

WCS audits:

  • Defined contribution plans
  • 401(k) plans
  • 403(b) plans
  • Defined benefit plans
  • Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs)

This breadth of experience gives our professionals exposure to different plan structures, administrative arrangements, and audit considerations.

Experience With Plans of Varying Sizes

WCS audits employee benefit plans with total plan assets ranging from under $5 million to more than $500 million.

That experience allows our team to work with both smaller plans and significantly larger, more complex benefit plans.

Knowledge of GAAP, ERISA & DOL Requirements

Our employee benefit plan professionals maintain specialized knowledge of the accounting and regulatory environment affecting benefit plans, including GAAP, ERISA, and Department of Labor requirements.

An Efficient, Organized Audit Process

A benefit plan audit can place additional demands on HR, finance, and administrative personnel.

Our experience helps us identify information requirements early, communicate clearly, and work efficiently with the various parties involved in the plan.

Focus on Internal Controls & Best Practices

The audit opinion is important, but the engagement can also help identify weaknesses in administrative processes and internal controls.

When appropriate, WCS communicates observations and recommendations that can help plan sponsors strengthen plan administration.

Form 5500 & Form 8955-SSA Preparation

In addition to the audit, WCS provides tax preparation services for employee benefit plans, including preparation of Form 5500 and Form 8955-SSA. Our detail-oriented approach results in the timely filing of Form 5500s, and because the same team understands both the audit and the filing, the audited financial statements and the return come together efficiently ahead of the deadline.

A Commitment to Audit Quality

Quality matters when selecting an employee benefit plan auditor.

Employee benefit plan audits are a specialized area of WCS’s accounting and auditing practice and are included in the firm’s external peer review process.

WCS received a pass rating on its most recent system peer review, the highest available peer review rating.

The engagements selected for that review included audits of employee benefit plans.

For plan sponsors, this provides an additional indication of WCS’s commitment to performing employee benefit plan audit engagements in accordance with applicable professional standards.

View WCS’s Peer Review Report

The DOL has previously sent letters to plan administrators of employee benefit plans across the country to discuss the importance of having a quality plan audit performed. Read the letter: Commitment to Quality – Why Auditor Selection Matters.

Frequently Asked Questions About Employee Benefit Plan Audits

An employee benefit plan audit is an independent examination of a benefit plan’s financial statements performed by a qualified independent CPA firm.

The audit provides an opinion on whether the plan’s financial statements are presented fairly under the applicable financial reporting framework.

WCS audits defined contribution plans, including 401(k) and 403(b) plans, as well as defined benefit plans and Employee Stock Ownership Plans (ESOPs).

WCS works with plans ranging from under $5 million to more than $500 million in total plan assets.

Certain employee benefit plans must include audited financial statements with their annual Form 5500 filing.

Whether a particular 401(k) plan requires an audit depends on applicable Department of Labor requirements and the plan’s circumstances.

Because the rules can change and exceptions may apply, plan sponsors should confirm current requirements based on their specific plan.

An independent qualified public accountant must perform an employee benefit plan audit when required.

Because benefit plan audits involve specialized accounting and regulatory requirements, plan sponsors should consider the firm’s specific employee benefit plan audit experience when selecting an auditor.

WCS performs employee benefit plan financial statement audits in accordance with generally accepted auditing standards, including ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audits and non-Section 103(a)(3)(C) audits, as applicable. The audit approach depends on the plan’s circumstances and whether management elects the ERISA Section 103(a)(3)(C) audit option and the applicable requirements are satisfied.

Audit procedures depend on the plan and engagement but can include financial statements, participant information, contributions, distributions, investments, participant loans, plan expenses, plan documentation, and related administrative processes.

Most engagements follow the same general steps: an initial planning meeting, an information request, fieldwork, follow-up questions, review of the draft financial statements, the final audit report, and coordination with the plan’s Form 5500 filing.

WCS sets the timeline with each plan sponsor at the start of the engagement so the audit is completed ahead of the filing deadline.

Information requirements vary by plan but may include plan documents, participant data, payroll records, contribution information, investment statements, distribution records, participant loan information, service-provider reports, and other financial documentation.

WCS provides clients with information requests in advance to help organize the audit process.

Preparation and communication are critical.

Maintaining accurate participant information, reconciling plan activity throughout the year, addressing administrative issues promptly, and gathering requested documentation before fieldwork begins can help reduce delays.

Working with an audit firm experienced in employee benefit plans can also improve efficiency because the audit team understands the information and coordination these engagements require.

Issues can involve participant eligibility, contribution remittances, employer contributions, distributions, participant loans, plan-document compliance, financial reporting, and internal controls.

Specific issues vary significantly by plan.

Yes.

WCS has offices in Hunt Valley and Bel Air, Maryland, and has a dedicated team of professionals specializing in employee benefit plan audits.

Contact WCS to discuss your plan and whether our audit team is the right fit for your organization.

Looking for an Experienced Employee Benefit Plan Auditor?

Employee benefit plan audits are too specialized to be treated as just another annual audit.

Plan sponsors need auditors who understand employee benefit plan financial reporting, ERISA, and Department of Labor requirements, and who can coordinate effectively with the administrators, recordkeepers, custodians, and other professionals involved with the plan.

WCS brings dedicated employee benefit plan experience to plans ranging from under $5 million to more than $500 million in assets.

Whether you’re preparing for your first plan audit, looking for a new auditor, or simply want a more efficient audit experience, our employee benefit plan professionals are ready to help.

Talk to a WCS employee benefit plan audit professional

Contact David Crisp, Partner, CPA.